Dodgers Announce Release of Some Former Loons

Last week, the Los Angeles Dodgers announced the release of some former Great Lakes Loons players.  Relief Pitcher Jason West, starter/reliever Matt Laney, and Catcher Andrew Edge were all given their release.  I had the unique opportunity of being the Clubhouse Manager for the  Low-A Great Lakes Loons for the 2012 season and was able to get to know these guys pretty well.  All three of them are first and foremost, great guys.  It was a pleasure to get to know them and work with them while they were with the club. 

Jason West, is a rare sidearmer with a big sweeping slider.  He pitched well for the Loons early on in the season.  In 14 games with the Loons, West threw 24.1 innings, had a 0-0 record with a 2.22 ERA.  He struck out 12, walked 16, gave up 16 hits and 6 earned runs.  He began to struggle with control which had to do with a lingering injury.  He was then demoted to Ogden in the Rookie Pioneer League where he struggled.  He appeared in 22 games, throwing 37.2 innings, posted a 3-0 record with a 5.02 ERA.  He struck out 34, walked 21, giving up 47 hits and 21 earned runs.  He was a leader among the relief corp while with the Loons.  Upon being sent down, his fellow relievers had a small statue that looked like West, painted and kept it in the bullpen throughout the rest of the season.  It was a great tribute to a great guy.  I hope he gets another chance with another organization, and if he finds his control, he can contribute nicely for another Minor League team.



Matt Laney is a big left handed pitcher that spent time both as a starter and a reliever.  The soft spoken kid from Chester, Virginia, had a tough season both with the Loons and the Raptors.  Overall he was 5-5 with a 5.55 ERA, while appearing in 26 games, 17 as a starter.  In 94.0 innings, he struck out 68, giving up 51 walks, allowing 107 hits and 58 earned runs.  Every team is always looking for a left-handed pitcher and hopefully he will catch on somewhere and fix his control problems.

Andrew Edge is a talented catcher, but for some reason, never received much of a chance last season.  The Dodgers control all roster moves and who is active on Minor League rosters.  He spent most of his time with the Loons on the inactive list.  When he did get into games, he produced.  In just 7 games with the Loons, he hit .421 in 23 plate appearances.  He had 8 hits (1 double, 1 triple), drove in 2 runs, scored 1 run, walked 3 times and had a 1.101 OPS.  He served as the bullpen catcher, put in a lot of hard work, and all though understandably frustrated at times, was always a positive teammate.  He was sent down to the Arizona League for some at-bats during the season, where he appeared in 16 games.  He had 57 plate appearances, had 10 hits (5 doubles), scored 8 runs and hit .208.  He rejoined the Loons for the final few games of the season.  I believe someone will pick him up and give him another chance in 2013. 

Five Writers Submit Blank Ballots for HOF

The Baseball Writers Association of America failed to elect anyone into the National Baseball Hall of Fame for 2013. Craig Biggio finished with the highest percentage, 68.2% (75% needed). Jack Morris finished second (67.7%), Jeff Bagwell third (59.6%), Mike Piazza fourth (57.8%), and Tim Raines fifth (52.2%).  There was much speculation among the writers that no one would be elected this year, and it turned out that they were right. 

The issue of performance enhancing drugs and who used, who didn't use, was obviously a divisive topic amongst the writers.  Some writers took the stance against not voting for Bonds, Clemens, Sosa, McGwire, etc, while other writers did vote for them.  I'm not going to say either side is right or wrong on their stance of why they voted for someone and didn't vote for others.  As long as they do their research and have solid reasons why, it's their opinion and are obviously entitled to it.  What really makes me mad though is the five writers that turned in a blank ballot...as in not voting for ANYBODY.  That to me is unacceptable.

Four of the five writers have made themselves known - Howard Bryant of ESPN, Chris Jenkins of the UT-San Diego, Jorge Ebro of El Nuevo Herald in Miami and Mark Faller of the Arizona Republic.

By submitting a blank ballot, you are punishing everyone on the ballot, not just the steroid era players.  They may think they are sending a message to the steroid era, however, they are essentially saying nobody belongs, even non-steroid era players.  If you want to send a message, only vote for guys outside of that era.  Guys like Jack Morris, Tim Raines, Lee Smith, Alan Trammell, Dale Murphy, who played most of their careers just outside of the era. 

My question to these five would be, are you going to submit another blank ballot next year? Why would doing it one time make any difference.  If you don't like what is going on, the strongest message they could make would be to just stop voting period and writing about your reasons why and call attention to the process and what needs to be changed.  If more writers did that, that could make a difference.  I would hope that wouldn't happen though.  Not voting for anyone doesn't change anything.  

If I Had a Baseball Hall of Fame Vote...

The National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum will announce it's class of 2013 on Wednesday. According to the Baseball Writers Association of America (BBWAA) rules, a writer can vote up to 10 candidates. If I had a vote, here would be my choices for the Hall of Fame (HOF) class of 2013.

Jack Morris This is Morris's 14th time on the HOF ballot. He had the most wins of the 1980s and was a big game pitcher. He was part of three World Championship teams (Detroit, Minnesota, Toronto). In the World Series he was 4-2 with a 2.96 ERA in 51.2 INN. He also pitched a 10 inning masterpiece in Game 7 of the 1991 series for Minnesota in their 1-0 win over Atlanta. In his career he compiled a 254-186 record with a 3.90 ERA and 175 complete games. One of the biggest criticisms of Morris has been his high ERA. To me, it doesn't matter. Give me a big game and Morris would be one of my top choices.

Tim Raines Raines was one of the top outfielders in the 1980s and played 23 years in the majors. He compiled 2605 hits, a .294 average and stole 808 bases. He was also a seven time all-star, winning the game's MVP in 1987 and won a batting title in 1986. He was one of the game's top base stealers and I think he deserves induction.

Alan Trammell Trammell was one of the many great shortstops of the 1980s. Often overshadowed by flashier players like Ozzie Smith, Barry Larkin, and Cal Ripken, Jr, Trammell was steady. He played 20 years for the Detroit Tigers. He compiled 2365 hits and a .285 average. He was a six time All-Star, four time Gold Glover, three time Silver Slugger award winner, and 1984 World Series MVP. His numbers compare to Larkin, and for all you SABR metrics geeks, his WAR of 67.1 is the same as Larkin's who was inducted into the HOF last year. I think it's time he gets in, although he probably won't. Hopefully, if the BBWAA doesn't induct him, the Veteran's Committee will induct him and his double play partner, Lou Whitaker, who fell of the ballot years ago...

Lee Smith Smith spent 18 years in the big leagues with eight different teams. He saved 478 games (3rd all-time) with a 3.03 ERA. Bruce Sutter, who was elected in 2006, had 300 saves. Smith was a seven time All-Star and won the Rolaids Relief man award three times. He lead the league in saves four times. There are not too many relievers in the HOF, but if Sutter got in, Smith should too.

Now for the Steroid Era players. This is a hot debate among the BBWAA. Some will vote for those players, many others refuse. It's hard to decide what the right thing to do is since many of them never officially tested positive, but were strongly suspected of using performance enhancing drugs (PEDs). I've thought about this for a long time, since this was the era that I became a huge baseball fan. So I have seen these players play their entire careers. I traveled to Milwaukee in 1998 just to watch Mark McGwire play two games in hopes seeing a bit of history (he did hit homerun #65 and would have had #66 but it was taken away by umpires who thought it hit off the top of the wall. The ball actually hit a fan in the chest and bounced back in play). So this is a tough one, but if I did have a vote, I would vote in all steroid players that have HOF numbers. The reason being, there was no real steroid policy back then. Many players were using. Maybe it's not a great reason, but until I see legitimate positive tests (and not just strong evidence or speculation), I would vote the players below in. Rafael Palmeiro did test positive in 2005 and I would not vote for him because of it. By the way, his suspension? Ten games...

Barry Bonds Bonds, who along with Roger Clemens, was the face of the Steroid Era. His numbers though, with or without enhancement, are remarkable. Bonds is the all-time career Homerun leader (762). He had a .298 average, 2935 hits, 601 doubles, 1996 RBI, 2558 BB (best all-time), and 514 stolen bases. He was a seven time Most Valuable Player, 14-time All-Star, eight time Gold Glover, 12-time Silver Slugger, and set the single season Homerun record with 73, in 2001. Enhanced numbers? More than likely, but he wasn't the only one in his era.

Roger Clemens Unlike with hitters, it's hard to determine what steroids can do for a pitcher. Does it make them throw harder or does it help with recovery? I'm not sure, but the horrible testimony (which he initiated) in front of Congress, has definitely increased everyone's suspicion to his PED use. Nevertheless, his career numbers were outstanding. 354-184 record, 3.12 ERA, 4672 strikeouts, 4916.2 IP, and 118 CG. He was a seven time Cy Young Award winner, won the MVP in 1986, and an 11-time All-Star. One of the best pitchers in the history of the game.

Sammy Sosa Sosa is another player who has a high probability of PED use. Along with Mark McGwire, they were part of the greatest Homerun race since 1961. Their chase of Roger Maris's single season record of 61 was truly an event to watch every night. He played 18 years and finished with a .273 average, with 609 HRs, 1667 RBI, and 2408 hits. He hit over 60 HRs in a season three times (only player to do it). He won the NL MVP in 1998, was a seven time All-Star, and a six time Silver Slugger winner. Again, probably enhanced numbers, but a part of the era.

Jeff Bagwell While under suspicion for PED use, there hasn't been a lot of talk about it, just asssumptions. Definitely less talk about use than Bonds, Clemens, and Sosa. Bagwell had a great 15 year career, all with the Houston Astros. He finished with a .297 average with 449 HRs, 1529 RBI and 2314 hits. He also walked 1401 times. He won the NL MVP in 1994, was NL Rookie of the Year in 1991, Gold Glove winner in 1994, Silver Slugger winner three times, and a four time All-Star. Unlike the previous three mentioned, I think he has a pretty good chance of being elected by the BBWAA.

Craig Biggio Biggio, Bagwell's teammate with Houston, has had very little PED controversy. Over a 20 year career, all with the Astros, he had a .281 average, 291 HRs, 1175 RBI, 414 SB, and 3060 hits. He started out as a Catcher, but spent the majority of his career as one of the best Second Basemen of his generation. He was a four time Gold Glove winner, five time Silver Slugger (one at Catcher and the rest at Second), and a seven time All-Star. According to Baseball Reference, his stats compare to HOFs, Robin Yount, Joe Morgan, Paul Molitor, Roberto Alomar, Cal Ripken, Jr, Brooks Robinson, George Brett, and future HOFer Derek Jeter. I believe Biggio will be an easier choice for the BBWAA than the others in the era. Not sure if he will make it in on the first ballot, but he will get in within the next couple of years for sure.

Mike Piazza Piazza is another one who some people think used PEDs. While it's not talked about nearly as much as Bonds, Clemens, and Sosa, there still is some doubt whether or not he put up untainted numbers. As it stands, he is arguably the best hitting Catcher of all-time. In 16 seasons, he finished with a .308 average, 427 HRs, 1335 RBI, and 2127 hits. He was 1993 NL Rookie of the Year and was selected to an All-Star team 12 times (won game MVP in 1996). He also won a Silver Slugger ten times. I think Piazza will be voted into the hall, just not sure it will be this year, his first year on the ballot.

There are my ten choices for the Hall of Fame. We will see who actually will be inducted into the 2013 class on Wednesday. Let the debate begin...